|





| |
October 2008 Newsletter
From Our President
To All Ford Credit Unions –
Important Ford Payroll Information
Please click on "Project Cavalier"
“Project Cavalier”
Shirley Meyer, President
716-826-6427
Click on the Applause Sign
below
to see our pictures from the CCACU 2008 Las Vegas Conference.
|
See you in Charleston,
South Carolina!
September 16-20, 2009 |
Don't
Underestimate the Negative Impact of Change
|

Do You Have an ACH Work Plan?
http://creditunionmagazine.com/story.php?doc_id=778


|
Ditch your bank for a credit union
You
aren't bound to your bank. Learn why credit unions deliver
big savings and better service for many consumers.
By
Liz Pulliam Weston
If the
response to "When
banks turn evil"
is any indication, a lot of you are really and truly sick of
your banks.
You're sick
of getting socked with fees, or tripped by hidden penalties,
or earning lousy interest rates. You're tired of being
treated like a nuisance rather than a customer. And yet you
have little hope that the bank down the street is any
better.
But who says
you have to settle for a bank? Relief could be as close as
the nearest credit union.
Because so
many people are fuzzy about the differences between banks
and credit unions, I'll highlight the three most important
distinctions:

·
Credit
unions are member-owned.
If you have an account at a credit union, you're a part
owner in the enterprise. That may not entitle you to use the
executive washroom -- your CU probably doesn't even have
an executive washroom -- but you're likely to be seen as a
person rather than as a "cost center."
·
Credit
unions are not-for-profit.
This status helps explain why interest rates tend to be
significantly better, and fees fewer and smaller, at credit
unions than at banks. Any profits credit unions do make are
distributed as dividends to their members. Contrast that
with banks, which continually invent new fees and policies
to boost profits (and to pay those stunning executive
salaries).
·
Banks hate
-- hate
--
credit unions. President Franklin D. Roosevelt
signed the Federal Credit Union Act into law in 1934 to
"promote thrift and thwart usury," and banks have pretty
much been gunning for them ever since.
Because of
their not-for-profit, cooperative structures, credit unions
are exempted from most state and federal taxes. Banks have
convinced themselves this is an unfair advantage and have
spent a lot of effort, plus a fortune in lobbying fees,
trying to legislate credit unions out of existence or at
least limit who can join. (I guess they thought the money
was better spent there than on, say, improving their
interest rates, reducing their fees or slashing their
telephone hold times.)
Are
you eligible? Almost certainly
Fortunately
for you, banks have failed pretty miserably in their efforts
to contain the competition. That's why the Credit Union
National Association, the CUs' trade group, can brag that
virtually everyone in the U.S. can belong to a credit union,
thanks to where they live, where they work or the
associations to which they belong.
|
Average interest rates at credit unions vs.
banks |
|
Consumer loans |
Credit unions |
Banks |
|
Credit card |
12.15% |
15.08% |
|
48-month new car |
6.21% |
7.59% |
|
48-month used car |
6.46% |
8.17% |
|
36-month unsecured |
11.12% |
12.73% |
|
Mortgage loans |
|
|
|
HELOC |
7.91% |
8.34% |
|
One-year ARM |
5.75% |
6.05% |
|
30-year fixed |
6.75% |
6.77% |
|
Savings |
|
|
|
Regular savings |
0.94% |
0.73% |
|
Interest checking |
0.63% |
0.62% |
|
Money market |
1.96% |
1.24% |
|
One-Year CD |
4.74% |
4.17% |
Source:
Datatrac, July 2007
The
nation's credit unions count 90 million members, and their
trade association estimates members save $8 billion a year
thanks to better interest rates and reduced fees.
Credit-union-issued credit cards, for example, tend not to
have annual fees or to charge punitive interest rates for a
single late payment. Most credit unions offer free checking
accounts, and penalties for overdrawing those accounts tend
to be lower: a $20 or $25 fee is typical, compared with up
to $39 a pop charged by banks.
Yet many
people discover the benefits of credit unions almost by
accident, said Pat Keefe, a spokesman for the credit-union
association. They'll join because they can get a decent rate
on a car loan, say, and only gradually discover that the
checking account has far fewer fees, the credit cards offer
better interest rates, and the mortgages aren't bad, either.
But
you don't have to wait until you need a loan. Usually,
finding a credit union is as easy as visiting your
employer's human resources department. If you don't work or
want more options, you can use the
"CU
Matchup"
tool at
JoinACU.org.
Based on
where we live, where my husband works and our various other
affiliations, the matchup tool spit out 31 local credit
unions that might accept us. Some of them had fairly narrow
membership requirements, like America's Christian Credit
Union, which requires attendance at certain evangelical
churches. Others were pretty darned broad, like Wescom
Credit Union, which allows anyone who lives, works, worships
or goes to school in Southern California to become a member.
Not perfect -- but not out to get you
Li ke
bank deposits, money in credit unions is insured for at
least $100,000 per account. Instead of the Federal Deposit
Insurance Corp., which insures bank deposits, the coverage
is provided by the National Credit Union Administration, but
both agencies are backed by the full faith and credit of the
federal government.
And you
typically aren't restricted to using your own credit union's
ATMs. Most CUs either offer fee-free access to a huge
network of ATMs or reimburse your fees if you use other
institutions' machines.
Are
credit unions perfect? Of course not. No institution run by
humans and their computers could possibly claim to satisfy
everyone all the time. Occasionally I'll hear of a credit
union that's instituted some silly fee, and too many have
opted for "bounce protection" instead of real overdraft
protection for their accounts. (For why the difference is
important, read "Don't
be duped by 'bounce protection.'")
But most of
the folks I talk to who have abandoned banks for credit
unions are thrilled they made the switch. If you're sick of
your bank, why don't you follow suit?
Columns by
Liz Pulliam Weston, the Web's most-read personal finance
writer, appear every Monday and Thursday, exclusively on MSN
Money. She also answers reader questions on the
Your Money message board.
|

Issues arise regarding quarterly UBIT filing
State-chartered
credit unions filing Internal Revenue Service (IRS) Form 990-Ts, the
"Exempt Organization Business Income Tax Return," and paying
unrelated business income tax (UBIT), will want to consult their
accountants or tax advisors to discuss the need to file quarterly
estimated tax returns on UBIT income, advises the Credit Union
National Association (CUNA). Consultation should be pursued whether
a credit union has filed a 990-T or plans to do so for 2008. A
handful of credit unions have been told by the IRS that they may be
subject to interest or penalties if they fail to submit quarterly
estimated tax reporting in years when they file, or expect to file,
a 990-T form. "Unfortunately, the tax law and the 990-T instructions
state that 'generally, an organization filing Form 990-T must make
installment payments of estimated tax if its estimated tax is
expected to be $500 or more," says CUNA General Counsel Eric
Richard. IRS Form 990-W can be used to help figure estimated UBIT
liability. The estimated tax is due April 15, June 15, Sept. 15, and
Dec. 15. On a related topic, a trial date of Aug. 31, 2009, has been
set for Bellco CU’s case challenging the government's policies on
UBIT issues.

NCUA guidance for weathering economic times
Current
economic conditions have profound implications for credit unions,
and the National Credit Union Administration (NCUA) has released
guidance for federally-insured credit unions. NCUA Letter #08-01 and
accompanying Supervisory Letter are “must reads” for credit union
management and volunteers. The Supervisory Letter discusses several
of the current risks facing the Credit Union Movement, provides
guidance for assessing mortgage portfolio risk management, and
recommends best practices for conducting risk focused supervision
and monitoring. Effectively addressing and resolving risk issues
requires open and clear communication between NCUA field staff and
credit union management, and continues to be a core element of the
Risk Focused Examination program.

CUs
up share of consumer credit to 9.2%
Increases
in both revolving and non-revolving credit helped credit
unions boost their share of total consumer installment
credit from 9.12 percent to 9.2 percent in July, the Federal
Reserve reported Monday.
Marketwide, total consumer
installment credit increased in July by 2.1 percent to an
annualized, seasonally adjusted $2.59 trillion; it was the
slowest pace recorded since last December. NAFCU Staff
Economist Katrin O’Connor said consumers’ pace of borrowing,
a measurement that does not include secured real estate
loans, was lower than expected.
Breaking down the marketwide
numbers, O’Connor said non-revolving credit increased at an
annual rate of 0.5 percent to $1.62 trillion, while
revolving credit surged by 4.8 percent to $969.9 billion.
“The poor showing of the former is a reflection of the
dismal vehicle-sales numbers reported in recent months,” she
noted.
At credit unions, total
consumer lending grew in July from $233.9 billion to $236.6
billion, non-seasonally adjusted. Non-revolving credit
lending increased by $2.3 billion to $204.6 billion;
revolving credit increased by $0.3 billion to $32 billion.
O’Connor said consumer
spending is likely to slow significantly during the second
half of the year as the effect of the rebate checks
continues to taper off and consumers face continued
challenges. “The weak labor market, tightening credit
conditions and falling home values do not bode well for
consumer installment credit demand or economic growth in
general,” the economist warned. “NAFCU expects total
consumer installment credit growth to slow from 5.7 percent
in 2007 to less than 5 percent this year.” (NAFCU)
|

Credit Union Snapshot
|
|
2Q '08 |
1Q '08 |
|
# of CUs |
8,337 |
8,425 |
|
Members
(millions) |
90.1 |
89.9 |
|
Total Assets
($ billions) |
812.7 |
782.0 |
|
Total Savings
($ billions) |
684.6 |
653.1 |
|
Net Cap.
/Assets |
11.1 |
11.5% |
|
Loans to Savings |
80.1 |
84.4% |
|
Loan Delinq. |
.97% |
.99% |
|
Key Economic Indicators
Credit Union Indicators
Rates by State
Rate Alert

Ethnic Minorities Lag in Credit Card Ownership
About half of Hispanics own credit cards.
Fewer Hispanic and African-American consumers
have credit cards and deposit accounts than do
consumers of other ethnic groups, according to a
report by the market-research firm
Synovate.
Sixty-nine percent of respondents who identified
themselves as African-American in a 2007
telephone survey and 51% of respondents who
identified themselves as Hispanic owned credit
cards, according to Synovate's 2008 U.S.
Diversity Markets Report, which was summarized
on
CardForum.com. That contrasts with 87% of
"general market" survey respondents—those who
are other than African-American or Hispanic.
About 90% of both African-American and general-market
respondents had bank or credit union accounts
(the survey did not distinguish between
checking, savings, and other types of deposit
accounts), while 77% of Hispanic respondents had
deposit accounts.
One reason a higher percentage of African-Americans and
Hispanics have less access to credit and
participate less in the U.S. financial system is
that incomes for both ethnic groups are lower
than average, according to Elliott Savitzky, a
Synovate vice president.
Other factors also come into play. For example, only 31%
of African-American respondents say financial
institutions treat them well compared with 36%
of Hispanic respondents who said so and 41% of
general-market respondents.
Marketing financial and payment services to underserved
portions of the U.S. population will pay off as
consumers' financial situations and credit
scores improve over time, says Savitzky.
"Issuers are always going to use credit scores
to minimize their risk," he says. "But if they
can market their products in underserved
communities and provide products and services
consumers haven't had access to in the past,
it's going to pay off."
The Hispanic population is growing more than
three times as fast as the overall U.S.
population, reports CUNA's 2008-2009
Environmental Scan. This ethnic group's average
income also is growing faster than that of the
overall population. About 60% of Hispanics now
earn between $25,000 and $75,000 annually, while
10% earn more than $100,000. For more on the
Hispanic market, underserved consumers, and
payment systems, check out the
2008-2009 E-Scan.
 |
|
Lessons
Learned From Microfinance
By Beth
Stetenfeld
Did you know:
 |
Forty percent to 60%
of the world's population is unbanked; |
 |
Twenty eight million
people in the U.S. have no financial account
relationship; and |
 |
About 45 million
people—19% of U.S. households—have account relationships
but continue to use various nontraditional financial
services to meet their needs? |
David
Grace, vice president of association services for the
World Council of Credit Unions (WOCCU), cited these
figures in a presentation on "Microfinance: The Downsizing
of Financial Services," at
CUNA Mutual Group's 2008 Discovery Conference in
Hollywood, Fla.
The financial services
competitive landscape is changing, Grace said:
 |
New microfinance institutions
are developing in new areas and in areas credit unions
served in the past. |
 |
Payday lenders,
pawnshops, and other nontraditional lenders are eroding
credit union market share. |
 |
Credit unions
need to pay attention to how other institutions serve
emerging demographic groups. |
The
crowded U.S. financial services marketplace includes
approximately 13,000 check cashing outlets, 14,000 pawn
shops, 10,000 payday loan stores, and 154,000 money transfer
agents.
At the same time,
credit unions' overall return on assets (ROA) will fall to
0.53% this year—the lowest level since 1980, according to
the
Credit Union National Association.
While membership growth
is up—to 2% in April 2008 from 1.2% in April 2007—that's
largely due to indirect lending, says Grace.
To improve ROA and
membership growth, consider microfinance options, he
suggested.
One
of the fastest-growing U.S. credit unions is
Latino Community Credit Union in Durham, N.C., Grace
said. Started in 2000 to serve the community's Latino
population, the credit union now boasts 12% ROA, 12% net
worth, a 1.9% delinquency ratio, and 55,000 members.
Seventy-five percent of
those members never had an account before joining the credit
union, and 99% were considered low income. The credit union
now has five branches and has expanded beyond Latino members
to welcome immigrants from around the world.
What lessons can other
credit unions learn from this model? Traditional financial
products—such as share draft accounts, savings, insurance,
and payment accounts—aren't the best acquisition tools for
most emerging markets, said Grace. Instead, consider
providing (or partnering with an organization to provide)
check cashing, remittances, cell phone bill pay, or other
transactional offerings.
Grace also recommends:
 |
Establishing a presence with the market you seek to serve.
Field-of-membership expansion isn't enough, Grace said.
The credit union needs a facility to serve unbanked
communities. |
 |
Building ties with trusted community organizations.
|
 |
Budgeting realistically for costs. Growth may be slower
and new members may be "less profitable" than expected.
|
 |
Reviewing the credit union's product mix. Consider
offering lower minimum balances, lower loan minimums,
second-chance loans, and anti-payday loans, he advised.
|
Beth Stetenfeld is managing editor for
Credit Union Magazine.
I |

Some banks watched for
Fannie, Freddie fallout

Treasury’s stock agreements with Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac place the
federal government first in claims before all other
shareholders in the entities, so banks and thrifts with
common or preferred shares in the entities have been
urged to let regulators know of any problems they may be
experiencing.
“The agencies believe that, while many institutions hold common or
preferred shares of these two government-sponsored
enterprises, a limited number of smaller institutions
have holdings that are significant compared to their
capital,” according to a joint statement Sunday by the
Federal Reserve Board, FDIC, Office of Thrift
Supervision and the Office of the Comptroller of the
Currency. Regulators said they stand ready to work with
institutions on capital restoration plans if needed.
Treasury says that activities under way to bolster the entities over the
next 16 months could result in some return to investors.
In any event, if losses do result, the shares held by
Treasury – “senior preferred” shares – will be protected
over all others, ensuring against additional cost to
taxpayers.
Federally insured credit unions don’t purchase stock in Fannie and
Freddie, but many do, like other institutions, maintain
investments in mortgage-backed securities. Treasury is
launching an MBS purchase plan to help stabilize the
market and ensure continued mortgage liquidity, a move
also intended to help ensure the stability of MBS
holdings. The program continues through 2009.
As of June 30, federally insured credit unions had about $39.3 billion
in agency/GSE mortgage-backed securities. That equaled
about 23.5 percent of all FICU investments.
Senate Banking Chairman Chris Dodd, D-Conn., said he plans to have
regulators testify “in the coming days” on the
conservatorship and funding decisions. He recalled
previous statements to Congress by Treasury Secretary
Henry Paulson that he believed such action, facilitated
by the recent housing and economic recovery statute,
would not be necessary.
House Financial Services Chairman Barney Frank, D-Mass., said he will
view the actions taken with an eye toward protecting
taxpayers, restoring market stability and “ensuring the
availability of affordable housing.” (NAFCU)
|

U.S. bankruptcies up nearly a third from ’07
U.S. consumer bankruptcy filings increased 29.2 percent in August on a
year-over-year basis – the same percentage increase in the first six
months of 2008, the American Bankruptcy Institute said.
The overall August consumer
filings total of 96,413 also marked the highest amount of monthly
bankruptcies since October 2005, the month the new bankruptcy law
took effect. Chapter 13 filings made up 33.2 percent of all consumer
cases in August, a slight increase from July.
The mid-year totals are based on
numbers from the U.S. courts. ABI said total number of bankruptcies
filed in the first six months of this year were up 29.2 percent from
the same period in 2007. Filings totaled 522,205 during the first
half of the calendar year of 2008, up from the 404,090 cases filed
in the same period in 2007.
Filings by individuals or
households with consumer debt increased 28.8 percent to 503,749 for
the six-month period ending June 30; the overall percentage of
consumers filing for chapter 13 protection fell slightly from 38.4
percent during the first half of 2007 to 33.8 percent in 2008.
Business filings for the same
six-month period ending June 30 totaled 18,456, representing a 42.1
percent increase over the first-half 2007 total of 12,985. Chapter 7
business liquidations increased by 54.7 percent; Chapter 11
reorganizations rose by 27.9 percent.
ABI Executive Director Samuel
Gerdano said the data numbers reflect the growing trend of
bankruptcy being seen as a way out of addressing financial
difficulties. “We expect bankruptcies to exceed 1.1 million by year
end,” Gerdano said. (NAFCU)

Ohio CU First FI in State to
Issue Cards Instantly
By
David Morrison
ENGLEWOOD, Colo. — A credit union is the first
financial institution in Ohio to begin issuing
its members credit and debit cards on-site,
according to the lending vendor of the instant
issuing technology.
Dynamic Card Solutions announced that the $136 million
Glass City Credit Union, headquartered in
Maumee, Ohio, is the first financial institution
in the state to start on-site issuing. The CU
said it would start instantly issuing debit
cards at its headquarters and two of its
branches.
"We had been considering instant issue for many years,"
said Mark Slates, president of Glass City FCU.
"Before we made the decision to go with DCS, we were
fortunate enough to see one of DCS' credit union
customer's instant issue programs on location.
We were not only impressed with the CardWizard
software itself, but after speaking with the
financial institution's staff and hearing the
simplicity of the program and positive feedback,
we were confident in selecting DCS as our
instant issue vendor of choice,” he said.
(CUTIMES)
|
|

Making an Economic Downturn
Work For You – And Your Members
For
most Americans, the economic picture isn’t very pretty these
days, yet forward-looking credit unions are finding innovative
ways not only to remain competitive in a sagging economy, but
even increase their market share. These insightful innovations
are boosting membership, too, attracting new members seeking the
best deal.
With the near-meltdown of the mortgage industry continuing to
dominate the media, the trickle-down effect is hitting many
industries hard, including the auto industry, with no let up in
sight. Fortunately, a number of credit unions are taking a
proactive response to the auto industry’s downturn and finding
that their concerted efforts are paying off.
To Amy Ogden, Consumer Loan Manager of Deseret First Credit
Union in Salt Lake City, the key is to stick to the basics – and
do them better than anyone else. “We’ve tried not to have a
knee-jerk reaction to the downturn in the economy, though we do
see that people aren’t spending as much,” she says. “We’re
looking to maintain consistency in our underwriting by focusing
on our borrowers as people, and doing our best to meet their
individual needs.”
For Ogden, a healthy dose of common sense is always helpful when
trying to cope successfully with a weakening economic climate.
“I think people are cautiously optimistic that the economy may
not be as bad as it seems to be from all the media coverage,”
she continues. “After all, with prices down, it’s a great time
to buy, and many people who realize this are taking advantage of
it.”
Meanwhile,
Raleigh, North Carolina’s Coastal Federal Credit Union has grown
their loan base by taking steps to further guarantee stability.
“We’ve started to employ credit insurance on most auto loans as
a way to ensure our financial stability. That definitely
represents an additional cost to us, but we feel that if you
want to do the best for your membership, it’s worth it,” says
Indirect Lending Manager Pete VanGraafeiland. “As a result,
we’ve been able to broaden the range of customers who can
qualify for loans. We’ve never dealt with sub-prime lending, for
a number of reasons, but we’ve still been able to broaden our
loans in order to carry near-prime loans.” The cost of the
credit insurance is graduated, according to the borrower’s
credit score, with Coastal Federal paying the cost up front by
foregoing percentage points for a couple of months.
Northeast Credit Union, Portsmouth, New Hampshire, is on a
growth curve despite the economic downturn, according to Senior
Vice President Mike Chisholm. A key factor in Northeast’s growth
has been a concerted effort to focus on soliciting and
maintaining new relationships with area dealerships. “We’re in a
relationship business, so we hired a fulltime rep to hit the
road, visit area dealers and solicit new relationships,” adds
Chisholm.
CoastHills
Federal Credit Union, serving California’s central coast, is
taking a more aggressive approach, according to Dal Widick,
Chief Operations Officer. “We believe it’s time for credit
unions to be aggressive in finding ways to turn their loan
volumes up. We must be creative both in our loans and in the way
we price our products,” he says. “Recently we decided to put our
money where our mouth is and lower our rates,” continues Widick.
“We began by offering super competitive vehicle loan rates to
those members with risk-free credit profiles.”
To Widick, CoastHills’ strategy has made a measurable difference
in the region. “Our dealers are very happy because they’ve
increased their sales by anywhere from 17 to 20%,” he says.
“We’re now doing enough business that it’s acting as a stimulus
to the local economy – we’ve made a huge difference in our
members’ lives and in our dealers’ lives. Why, we got 400 new
members last month alone – people who had heard about our
products, walked in and simply asked, ‘How do I join?’”
By taking a proactive approach to the current economic downturn,
credit unions are finding that success, even market growth, in
the auto lending arena can be achieved.
-- excerpted from CUDL’s Merge Magazine Summer, 2008 |
A Gen Y
Perspective: What CUs Can Learn from Nintendo?
By
Dane Coalson, Industry Analyst, Callahan & Associates, Inc
.
Credit unions are facing
competition at a level they have never seen before. Online, high
yielding savings accounts are attracting deposit dollars. Banks
remain aggressive with credit card offers, even in the current
economic climate. Despite positive numbers in the 2nd quarter,
credit unions continue to experience slow growth, especially when it
comes to attracting new members, as industry membership only
increased 1.25% in the past 12 months.
On the identification front, consumers are increasingly unable to
differentiate a bank from a credit union, particularly since many
banks are using credit-union-like messaging in their marketings. At
the same time, members are demanding more from their financial
institutions, such as easier access through online and mobile
channels, as well as other convenient technologies.
What Does It Take to Stay Relevant?
Every single day, companies reinvent themselves to succeed in their
specific marketplace. But what does this take? Here is one example:
Nintendo, the patriarch of the rapidly expanding personal video game
market, has accomplished something amazing over the past two years.
They cast off their outdated image and moved from third place
amongst their competitors to the top spot in the gaming world. This
success occurred because of a single innovative differentiator…
Nintendo started out at the top of the heap in 1985 as the first
personal video gaming system that enjoyed widespread popularity. For
nearly two decades, they successfully held their own against
competing gaming systems from the Sega Genesis to the Sony
Playstation. But the tide turned against Nintendo as we moved into
the new millennium and they launched the Gamecube.
The competition, most notably Sony's Playstation 2 & Microsoft's
Xbox console, decided to embrace new trends that were emerging in
the gaming industry. While Nintendo's flagship games continued to
focus on wholesome standards, such as the Mario or Zelda franchises,
while edgier games with a more mature focus were developed for the
other consoles.
The gaming industry was changing, as many of the children who grew
up playing Nintendo became more interested in titles aimed at
adults, such as Grand Theft Auto and Halo. Nintendo’s Gamecube was
completely dominated by its competitors and it did not look like
Nintendo's traditional approach could effectively compete in the
rapidly changing environment.
How did Nintendo Get Back on
Top?
They came up with something that the market had never seen before,
something that was truly innovative and clearly differentiated them
from their competitors.

They introduced a completely motion-sensitive controller and gaming
system- the Wii, which launched in 2006. It is the first video game
system that allows people to manipulate their actions in the video
game using body movement, instead of solely relying on button and
joystick combinations. This new capability allows the system to
develop different types of games that have never been seen before,
including functional fitness applications. The Wii not only
resonates strongly with youth, but is the first system to be
universally desired by every age range, from elementary school
children through seniors at retirement centers. The system is so
popular, that the Wii continues to fly off the shelves wherever it
appears, even two years after its initial release.
How Can Credit Unions Learn From This?
Credit unions struggle to break out of the pack with their
traditional message of “member value” simply because the entire
financial services industry has co-opted the "we have your best
interest at heart" message and constantly bombard the public with
it. The industry needs to find new, fresh ways to get their
message across and visibly demonstrate their difference to potential
members! This is no easy task, but I think that industry
professionals need to take the time to try and come up with some
answers…
One Example of Industry
Innovation:
Musicstream
LIVE is an emerging initiative in the credit union industry that
has recently caught my attention. This program will combine live
music concerts from up-and-coming artists at high schools across the
country with online streaming music, free downloads, and social
networking. Credit unions will be able to stage these concerts at
their local schools and have an opportunity to bring their message
to young people in an exciting environment. One of the biggest
strengths of this venture is the wide variety of high-profile
partners that have already been secured. These partners include
music industry heavyweight BMI (Broadcast Music Incorporated) and
the Future Business Leaders of America, which have a chapter in
nearly every high school across the nation and will use their
student members to promote the concerts.
I have been unable to find any type of similar program offered by
other financial institutions. Keep in mind that musicstream LIVE is
still in the planning phase, and will come to market in early 2009.
This initiative has the potential to allow credit unions to
differentiate themselves from competition in the youth market and I
will certainly be keeping my eye on it.
What Ideas Do You Have?
I would like to ask anyone reading this article to leave a comment.
Share with all of us, what do you think could be an example of a
differentiator for your credit union? Don’t worry about what is
currently feasible. If anything is possible, and price and
implementation no object, what would you desire from your financial
institution?

Related Resources:
I will be participating in a
Gen Y panel discussion that will examine how CUs can apply 15
successful strategies that the retail industry has used to appeal to
Gen Y. At the end of September, Callahan will also host a webinar
focused on helping CUs attract the
18 & under crowd.

|
|